Blogtable: Knicks or Lakers in future?

Each week, we’ll ask our stable of scribes across the globe to weigh in on the most important NBA topics of the day — and then give you a chance to step on the scale, too, in the comments below.


BLOGTABLE: Kyrie’s 57 or Klay’s 37? | The rest issue … | Brighter future: Knicks or Lakers?



VIDEOLooking back on better days for the Knicks and Lakers

> Phil Jackson and Jeanie Buss had an in-arena date last week, with Jackson’s Knicks getting a victory over Buss’s Lakers. Which of these high-profile NBA executives will be more satisfied with their team’s rebuild 12 months from now?

Steve Aschburner, NBA.com: Buss. The Lakers, as soon as they have money to spend, will be able to flex their legacy and locale advantages in free agency in ways the Knicks’ miserable recent history will preclude. Also, I get the sense that upbeat Jeanie is more easily satisfied than cantankerous Phil, so personality plays a role in this too.

Fran Blinebury, NBA.com Hoo boy, that’s a bar so low that Gumby couldn’t limbo under it. Satisfaction is hardly the word to use. I’ll take a flyer on the Lakers with a healthy Julius Randle and their top five draft pick roughly co-existing with Kobe Bryant’s latest comeback over a top-flight rookie and Carmelo Anthony learning the secrets of the triangle. But neither sniffs the playoffs again, so misery can continue holding hands and making goo-goo eyes with company.

Scott Howard-Cooper, NBA.comMore satisfied being the key, since neither will be satisfied in 12 months. The Lakers will have made the most progress by this time next year, with one important disclaimer: as long as they keep their lottery pick that is top-five protected. Neither will be a good situation, barring a shocking veteran pickup in the summer. But the Lakers will be the better of the not good.

Shaun Powell, NBA.comWell, Jeannie isn’t on contract, so I guess Phil will want and need to see some rather significant improvement a year from now. I’ll give the edge to Phil. Kobe is already on record saying the Lakers shouldn’t do anything rash and destructive just to surround him with ready-to-win talent next season, so the Lakers should continue with a gradual rebuild. Meanwhile, Phil convinced the Knicks to invest so much into Carmelo Anthony that some justification is in order for the Zen Master.

John Schuhmann, NBA.com: New York. The Lakers already have a Lottery pick — Julius Randle — in hand and, with the league’s fourth worst record, only a 17 percent chance of losing their top-five protected pick to the Philadelphia 76ers. But the Knicks have the better and younger star player, as well as a better chance at one of the top two picks, where the true difference makers will likely be. Furthermore, Derek Fisher probably has a better ability to coach a young team up than Byron Scott, who floundered in a similar opportunity in Cleveland.

Sekou Smith, NBA.com: Jeanie Buss has the Lakers’ history of always finding their way back to relevance on her side. The lure of playing for a franchise smothered in championship lore and in one of the most desirable locations on the planet will somehow win out. The Knicks have so much ground to make up that they’d need some blind luck to beat the Lakers to the finish line of respectability. I just don’t see them getting there before the Lakers a year from now. Free agency this summer will be the key, of course. Whoever gets the most done in July and August will have the best shot at winning this one.

Ian Thomsen, NBA.com: The Lakers are going to be able to sign someone good this summer, add another high pick to Julius Randle (the luck of the lottery willing), hope for a meaningful comeback year from Kobe Bryant, and then go back into free agency in 2016 with the heavy tailwind of the new TV contract and the extra cap space it will create. Jeanie is a better salesperson than Phil, and she has more to sell.

Lang Whitaker, NBA.com’s All Ball blogPhil. The reason I have to give the Zen Master the nod is that both organizations will presumably, at some point, have to tear things down before they build them up. And the Knicks are well on their way to doing that. This time next year, the Lakers will be nearing the end of Kobe Bryant’s contract and trying to figure out where to go next. And if history is any teacher, Lakers management hasn’t exactly inspired confidence.

8 Comments

  1. kilo says:

    Lakers will attract no one because no one good wants to play with Kobe.

  2. SYDALE says:

    Knicks are in the East, so that’s ONE postive for them… They’ll likely have the higher draft pick as well… So, I’ll say that the Knicks will be happier a year from now… they might have 35 wins this time next year…

  3. harriethehawk says:

    The Fakers or the Knickerbonkers? Who is most likely to continue to be a bottom feeder? I’m going w/ the Knickerbonkers. Once Kobe retires, they can literally clean house. Carmello Anthony has that stupid contract (well so does Kobe). Guess what, I don’t care for either of these loser teams. Why is this even a pertinent question???

  4. dustydreamnz says:

    I think the Knicks. A lot will depend if Kobe retires though because that would give the Lakers more cap space.

  5. Jose says:

    Phi Jackson should consider trading for players whom will Enjoy & Comfortable Playing in his triangle offense system.. I think some of the current Knicks Players are not comfortable with it.. I think Phil & D-Fish should talk about hiring Phil Jackson’s former Player to teach the young players about playing comfortably with the Triangle

  6. Indiana'sownLarryBird says:

    Neither, the way they are making basketball decision’s the future is not looking good for either. But they both got money, and the two biggest city’s in america, Broadway or Hollywood.

  7. I got the Lakers, too. New York and it’s state tax laws sealed the deal.

    Hey guys, I just want to bring attention to everyone about a contest I came across that gives up to 300 bucks to the winner easy! Just guess the basketball illustration and that’s it, no fuss. Like stealing candy from a baby! Here is the contest link: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Never-Foul-A-Jump-Shooter/825946614115741